While most of us know that reflection is a key to helping students
learn new information, many people don't have a practical model to use
when facilitating reflection exercises with their students. Let's
examine a 4 step learning model and how it might benefit students in
any setting.
Step 1: The Experience
This
could be anything. Maybe it's a test, a group project, a guest
speaker, a lecture, a worksheet, or recess. Anything can be reflected
upon for the sake of gaining valuable applicable insights.
Step 2: Observation (What)
As
facilitators we often call this step the "what" step, because we ask a
lot of questions that begin with that word. What just happened? What
emotions did you feel? What was challenging about the activity? What
behaviors did you notice? This is a time to observe the observable.
Things like what people said to each other or how someone reacted to a
rise in anxiety are excellent things to examine in this step.
Step 3: Add Meaning (So What)
People
have a set of learned lenses that we use to examine life and add
meaning to our experiences. In this step we take the observable data
that we've talked about in step 2 and synthesize it into some
conclusions about the experience. We call this step "so what" because
we examine our behavior or the information gained during the experience
and ask, "So what does this mean for our life, team, world, etc?" This
is a key step for the facilitator to affect life change because this is
where the lenses our students use when making decisions will come to
the surface. The greatest degree of impact you can make in your limited
interactions with students will come from challenging the lenses they
see the world through. While giving information is great, changes in
behavior, how they actually react to and use that information, will
only come through changes in how they see their worlds.
Step 4: Application (Now What)
At
NLR we tell our facilitators that if we spend an hour doing a team
building exercise and don't end that time with application, we've just
wasted an hour of everyone's life. What good is an experience if it is
never applied in a meaningful and practical way? This step seeks to
help people move toward applying new information by asking the
questions, "Now that we've had our experience and discovered something
meaningful about it, what should our response be? How do we live
differently with this new information?" Remember that life changing
application doesn't have to be the stereotypical touchy feely moment
that you may think of (although there's nothing wrong with that), but
that any small behavior change has large implications in daily living.
Something as routine as an elementary student deciding to apply
information and always begin a new sentence with a capitol letter is a
big deal that will influence them for the rest of their lives.
Confucius
is quoted as saying, "Study without reflection is a waste of time;
reflection with study is dangerous." May we, as people with influence
over others, use reflection as a tool to do what we do more
effectively. And for those of you who are wrapping up the summer and
preparing for another long school year, use these tools yourself. What
happened this year? What does that mean? What can you change in
yourself to do an even more excellent job in the future?
For a more in depth look at critical reflection you can read this article:
http://agelesslearner.com/intros/experiential.html